Magazine issues » October 2020

Exchange-traded funds: Mapping Hong Kong’s ETF market

Hong_KongAssets under management in exchanged-traded funds are burgeoning, but growth is concentrated in the US and Europe, writes Fiona Rintoul. By the end of August 2020, the ETF/exchange-traded product (ETP) market had reached a record US$7.1 trillion of assets under management (AuM), according to the consultancy ETFGI, but just $45 billion of that was attributable to the Asia-Pacific hub of Hong Kong. Trading in ETFs on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange typically accounts for less than 5% of total volumes. This does not mean that Asian investors are not buying ETFs, but they were perhaps slower to the party than US and European investors. They have, however, been catching up in recent years. “All the big tickets that get traded into Europe and the US by Asian institutions don’t show up when you start to talk about size of platforms,” says Sean Cunningham, head of Asia ETFs at JP Morgan Asset Management (JPMAM). “It doesn’t take into account the trading that is happening cross-border.” The appetite for these products among Asian investors is mounting, but they accounted for less than 5% of ETF AuM in Hong Kong at the end of 2019. Some believe this situation could be about to change – potentially driven by cross-listings of European Ucits ETFs. Overcoming obstacles
The current low level of cross-listings of Ucits ETFs in Hong Kong – only DWS’s Xtrackers are listed on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange (HKSE) – is partly due to historical obstacles. In 2019, Euroclear created a link to the HKSE to overcome some of them. The link removed settlement obstacles for Hong Kong market makers dealing in European Ucits ETFs. This means Ucits ETFs can now be settled on the same day, avoiding spreads of 200 basis points or more. “We have demonstrated that issuers using Euroclear’s international structure can move European-traded ETFs to Hong Kong the same day,” says Mohamed M’Rabti, deputy head of capital markets at Euroclear. But business has not flowed into Hong Kong as quickly as it did in other markets, such as Mexico, where M’Rabti helped set up similar links. The HKSE continues to be dominated by a not-very-diverse selection of locally listed ETFs. “You would struggle to build a global portfolio,” says Jackie Choy, director of ETF fund research, Asia at Morningstar. “There are a lot of Chinese equity products of different kinds. In fixed income, the exposure is largely to Asian and some Chinese indices.” For M’Rabti, the key to changing this is education. Asian buyers of Ucits ETFs (or US-listed ETFs) still tend to go directly to the exchange where the product has its primary listing, believing that this will give them access to better liquidity. But in some ways, this is a false perception. “In terms of liquidity, you should not worry about what you see on the screen on the stock exchange,” says M’Rabti. “You could at any time go to the primary market.” Accounting for optics
The desire for liquidity is a strong one, however, and the point about look-through liquidity is sometimes lost on investors. Furthermore, liquidity constraints are sometimes prescribed by risk frameworks. “A lot of institutions like to see big blocks of liquidity,” says Cunningham. “Some of them are sophisticated enough to understand that the optical liquidity is not always the most important thing, but for some institutions it really is. And there are certain institutions that have risk-framework restrictions around trading funds that aren’t of a certain size.” Cunningham has seen “a real shift of Asian institutions going to the Ucits product line to get their global exposures”. But this is driven by the deepening liquidity of the European ETF market, which allowed it to catch up with the US. JPMAM prefers to meet that demand through products listed in Europe and the US and has not cross-listed anywhere in the Asia-Pacific region outside China. “In China we have a local platform, so we’re putting product on the ground in there,” says Cunningham. DWS sees it differently. The ability to cross-list Ucits ETFs from Europe and the fact that the Ucits framework is well accepted in Hong Kong attracted it to the region as a hub. “Cross-listing helps us to benefit from economies of scale, which is key in the passive business,” says Marco Montanari, DWS’s head of product management for Asia-Pacific. Access to China is another reason behind DWS’s choice – though this is more about forward planning than current sales. “Hong Kong has historically benefited from schemes that would allow mainland China investors to buy in Hong Kong, and therefore it provides potential opportunities to tap into the mainland China market in the future,” says Montanari. “We hope to see more schemes to allow mainland China investors to buy Hong Kong-listed ETFs, and that these schemes will also include Ucits ETFs cross-listed in Hong Kong.” ETF evolution
So, what prospect is there of Hong Kong developing into an ETF hub for the Asia-Pacific region? It is a bit of a chicken-and-egg scenario; the more products that list, the more liquidity there will be to attract investors. And there is certainly a rationale to cross-listing European and US-listed ETFs that invest in the Asia-Pacific region. “The evolution of trading your own market in your own hours will start to be something that clients will demand going forward,” says Cunningham. “The spreads on these products get naturally tighter when the underlying markets are actually open and trading. Funds that cater to a certain client and need will get traction because that is where clients will find the tightest price.” A Euroclear report published this year entitled ‘The stars are aligning for Hong Kong’s ETF market’ predicts that demand for ETFs in Asia-Pacific will rise from $1.5 trillion to $5 trillion over the next five years. To meet that demand, M’Rabti would like to bring all the products in Europe that match Asian investors’ needs to Hong Kong via cross listings. Progress has been made to facilitate this. The Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) relaxed its master-feeder regime last December and market makers are now exempted from paying stamp duty when engaging in primary market activity in Hong Kong-listed ETFs. However, there is more to be done. As yet, there is no mutual fund recognition between Hong Kong and Ireland, and M’Rabti says it can take six to nine months for funds to be authorised. Furthermore, if the prospectus in Europe changes, it must be approved by the Hong Kong regulator. “There is a will to come to the market, but there is a regulatory burden,” says M’Rabti. Another problem is the absence of a retail market for ETFs in Hong Kong. This is largely down the fact that Hong Kong, like many other Asian markets, has not undergone a retail distribution review, and so there is little incentive for the banks that dominate retail distribution to sell low-cost ETFs. “Hong Kong is already a regional trading hub for ETFs, but it could further enhance its position by reforming its distribution system from a commission-based system into a fee-based system,” says Montanari. “Other jurisdictions that implemented similar initiatives saw significant growth in ETF trading.” Such a move is not really in sight, but other regulatory improvements – including perhaps bilateral mutual fund recognition between Hong Kong and Ireland, which accounts for 62% of the European ETF market – may lie closer. “It’s a question of time,” says M’Rabti. “Asset managers and other players in the market are lobbying to see how we could ease the regulatory burden.” Then there is the issue of China. If Montanari’s hope that there will be schemes to allow mainland China investors to buy Hong Kong-listed ETFs is realised, Hong Kong could become a truly interesting hub for the Asia-Pacific region. Such a possibility might come to pass through the Greater Bay Area plan, suggests M’Rabti. This grand project includes discussions about a ‘Wealth Connect’ between Guangdong, Macau and Hong Kong. As yet, however, the scope of this initiative has not been defined. “We will have a clearer view next year,” says M’Rabti. © 2020 funds global asia

Industry comments

Investing in tomorrow’s world

investmentAt times like these, HSBC Asset Management easily pivots towards emerging markets.

The spotlight on growth markets and the need to be nimble and dynamic is ever-sharper, given the difficulty in predicting monetary policy in the world’s major nations.

Sponsored feature: Navigating the complexities of FX execution and currency risk

A comprehensive, cost-effective, and transparent currency overlay hedging solution is crucial to mitigate FX exposure risks in the complex landscapes of Japan and China's FX markets, explains Hans Jacob Feder, PhD, global head of FX services at MUFG Investor Services.


The emergence of AI-powered funds

Contradictory market sentiments from commentators have impeded the decision-making powers of the first wave of AI-powered ETFs, says Alvin Chia of Northern Trust Asset Servicing.

Transitioning to an era of scarcity

The world is transitioning from an era of commodity abundance to one of undersupply. Ben Ross and Tyler Rosenlicht of Cohen & Steers believe this shift may result in significant returns for commodities and resource producers over the next decade.

Asia credit: An outsized winner in the region’s energy transition?

Ross Dilkes, fixed income portfolio manager at Wellington Management, examines the opportunities and risks for bond investors presented by the region’s decarbonisation agenda.

A quiet revolution in Japan’s corporate governance

revolution, Japan, corporate governance, Shareholders, corporate, governance, standards, improvement, Tetsuro Takase, SuMi TrustShareholders in Japan no longer accept below-par corporate governance standards. Changes are taking place, but there are still areas for improvement, says Tetsuro Takase at SuMi Trust.

Executive Interviews

Executive interview: PGIM CEO on where the ESG flowers should bloom

Sep 27, 2021

David Hunt, president and chief executive of PGIM, tells Romil Patel about leading a top 10 global asset manager in times where “empowering and encouraging the kind of investment decisions as...

Executive interview: Nicolas Moreau’s orderly transition

Jul 12, 2021

Nicolas Moreau, CEO of HSBC Asset Management, is moving to Asia as the firm looks to connect more directly with the region’s growth story. ESG is also a key focus – including the ‘just’ carbon...


India: An “obvious choice for global investors”

Jun 22, 2023

Funds Europe, the sister publication of Funds Global Asia, hosted an India investment discussion with two seasoned experts and asked if India is the ‘last one standing’ from the Brics phenomenon. We also hear that for India, the inclusion of Indian bonds in a major index may not be the desired...

Roundtable: Singapore comes of age as an Asian ESG hub

Dec 01, 2021

Strong ESG credentials strengthen the case for Singapore as a leader in Asia of the post-Covid recovery. Our panel discusses the risks and opportunities.